Ever found yourself standing in a gear shop, torn between a duffel bag and a camping backpack, wondering which one will serve you better on your next outdoor adventure? You’re not alone in this dilemma, and the choice you make could significantly impact your camping experience.

According to Outside Magazine’s gear testing team, which evaluated over 70 top duffel bags and backpacks, these two gear types serve distinct purposes beyond just shape and carry style. Their tests reveal duffel bags excel in rugged, heavy-loading scenarios thanks to wide openings and forgiving internal space. Meanwhile, camping backpacks shine in organized, weight-distributed loads, especially when traversing trails or uneven terrain. 

Choosing between a duffel and a backpack comes down to matching your camping needs, with duffels offering easy access and overflow gear space, and backpacks providing structured load support and hands‑free mobility

Understanding Duffel Bags for Camping

MIER Large Waterproof Duffel Bag For Camping

Buy on Amazon

A duffel bag is essentially a large, cylindrical bag with a single main compartment and a long zip opening at the top. Duffel bags are designed for, and almost always used for, carrying clothes and gear. They typically have a long zip opening at the top, limited pockets, and a single spacious compartment.

Key Features of Camping Duffel Bags

Most duffel bags come with simple carrying options like bale handles or a single shoulder strap. However, modern camping duffels often include backpack straps that can be tucked away when not needed. Many styles come with removable backpack straps for easy carrying, making them more versatile for outdoor use.

The beauty of a duffel bag lies in its simplicity and spacious interior. Unlike backpacks with multiple compartments, duffels offer one large space where you can pack everything together. This makes them incredibly efficient for packing bulky items, such as sleeping bags, camp chairs, or multiple sets of clothing.

Best Use Cases for Duffel Bags in Camping

A duffel is great for cabin or car camping, where you won’t be carrying your gear over long distances. They excel in situations where you need to transport a lot of gear from your car to a nearby campsite. The wide opening makes it easy to see everything at once and grab what you need quickly.

Car Camping Adventures: When you’re driving right up to your campsite, duffels shine. You can pack bulky items like sleeping bags, camp chairs, and multiple changes of clothing without worrying about weight distribution. The large capacity means fewer trips from the car to the campsite. Pro tip: Pack heavier items at the bottom and lighter items on top for easier carrying from your vehicle.

Cabin and Lodge Stays: Duffels are perfect for base camp situations where you set up in one location and don’t move around much. With a good duffel, all your stuff can go in one bag and you can hang it off a bunkbed or nail, making organization simple in cabins or established campsites. The lack of rigid structure means they conform to tight storage spaces better than hard suitcases.

Festival Camping: Music festivals and organized camping events favor duffels because you typically set up once and stay put. The easy packing and unpacking make it simple to find costumes, extra clothes, or gear quickly. Many festival-goers prefer waterproof duffels to protect electronics and clothing from unexpected weather.

RV and Glamping: When comfort is the priority and space isn’t limited, duffels offer maximum storage without the complexity of backpack features you won’t need. They’re also easier to store in RV compartments and don’t take up valuable closet space when not in use.

Group Camping: Duffels work well as shared gear bags for group camping trips. You can designate one duffel for cooking equipment, another for group shelter items, making it easy for anyone to access shared resources. The wide opening means multiple people can access gear simultaneously without creating bottlenecks.

Beach and Lake Camping: Waterproof duffels are excellent for camping near water, where sand and moisture are constant concerns. They’re easier to rinse off than backpacks with complex strap systems and dry faster due to their simple construction.

Winter Camping (Drive-In): When car camping in winter, duffels accommodate bulky winter gear like heavy coats, boots, and extra blankets more efficiently than backpacks. The flexible design adapts to oddly-shaped winter camping essentials.

Family Camping with Young Children: Parents often prefer duffels for family camping because kids’ gear (toys, extra clothes, comfort items) can be packed together and accessed quickly. The simple design means even children can help pack and unpack their belongings.

Understanding Camping Backpacks

Tripole Walker 65 Litres Rucksack

Buy on Amazon

Camping backpacks are designed with a completely different philosophy. They prioritize weight distribution, organization, and hands-free mobility. Unlike duffels, backpacks feature multiple compartments, external attachment points, and ergonomic designs that make carrying heavy loads over distances much more comfortable.

Key Features of Camping Backpacks

The most obvious difference is the dual shoulder strap system that distributes weight evenly across your back and shoulders. With two shoulder straps, travel backpacks are easier to carry over distances than a duffel. This makes them indispensable for any camping trip that involves hiking to your destination.

Camping backpacks also offer superior organization with multiple pockets, compartments, and external attachment points. You can separate your gear logically – sleeping system in the bottom, food in side pockets, rain gear easily accessible, and electronics in padded compartments.

Best Use Cases for Camping Backpacks

A backpack is for hiking. Backpacks take up more room in the car and are not needed to move gear around after you are set up on site. This perfectly summarizes when backpacks shine – any time you need to carry your gear on your back for extended periods.

Backpacking and Wilderness Trips: Multi-day hikes into remote areas where you carry everything you need on your back. The weight distribution and organization features become essential when you’re hiking 10+ miles with all your gear. Look for backpacks with load-lifter straps and padded hip belts to transfer weight from your shoulders to your hips for long-distance comfort.

Day Hiking with Overnight Gear: When you hike to a campsite during the day and return the next day, backpacks make the journey comfortable and keep your hands free for trekking poles or navigation. The external attachment points let you secure sleeping pads, tents, and other bulky items outside the main compartment.

Public Transportation Camping: If you’re taking buses, trains, or planes to reach your camping destination, backpacks are much easier to manage through crowds and tight spaces than duffels. The hands-free design means you can navigate stairs, escalators, and narrow aisles while maintaining balance and control.

Technical and Mountaineering Expeditions: Climbing trips and technical outdoor adventures require the specialized attachment points, gear loops, and organization that only backpacks provide. Features like ice axe loops, rope attachment points, and dedicated compartments for technical gear are essential for safety and efficiency.

Through-Hiking and Long-Distance Trails: Multi-day or multi-week trail adventures like the Appalachian Trail or Pacific Crest Trail require the comfort and organization that backpacks excel at. The ability to access specific items without unpacking everything becomes crucial when you’re living out of your pack for weeks.

Urban Camping and Hostels: When you’re moving between different camping locations frequently, backpacks make transportation much easier while keeping your hands free. They’re also less conspicuous in urban environments and easier to secure to prevent theft.

Solo Camping Adventures: When camping alone, especially in remote areas, backpacks offer better mobility and the ability to quickly relocate if weather or safety concerns arise. The organized compartments help you find emergency items quickly in low-light conditions.

Photography and Wildlife Watching Trips: Backpacks with specialized camera compartments and easy-access pockets are perfect for camping trips focused on photography or wildlife observation. The stable platform and hands-free design let you move quietly and set up shots without disturbing your subjects.

Hunting and Fishing Camping: Sportsmen need the mobility and organization that backpacks provide when accessing remote hunting or fishing locations. Specialized hunting backpacks often include features like rifle holders, game storage, and scent-proof compartments that duffels simply can’t accommodate.

Difference Between Duffel Bag Vs Camping Backpack

1. Storage Capacity and Space Efficiency 

When it comes to raw storage capacity, duffel bags typically win. A duffel bag, compared to a backpack, is often more spacious, allowing the user to load more goods or numerous items simultaneously. The lack of internal dividers and the flexible construction means you can stuff more gear into a duffel than you could into a similarly sized backpack.

However, this advantage comes with trade-offs. The lack of organization in duffels means you might spend more time digging for specific items. Backpacks sacrifice some raw capacity for better organization and easier access to your gear.

Consider your packing style too. If you’re someone who likes to pack systematically and access specific items without unpacking everything, a backpack’s multiple compartments will serve you better. If you prefer to pack everything together and don’t mind unpacking to find things, a duffel’s open design is more efficient.

2. Comfort and Carrying Options

This is where the biggest difference between duffel bags and camping backpacks becomes apparent. Backpacks are designed from the ground up for comfortable carrying over long distances. The weight distribution across two shoulders, padded straps, and often additional features like hip belts and chest straps make backpacks significantly more comfortable for extended carrying.

Duffels, even those with backpack straps, aren’t designed with the same ergonomic considerations. If you plan on walking extended distances and carrying larger loads, it’s a good idea to consider duffels with backpack-style straps, but they still won’t match a true backpack’s comfort level.

However, duffels excel in other carrying scenarios. Their grab-and-go nature with sturdy handles makes them perfect for quick movements around camp or loading into vehicles. The single-strap design also works well for short carries where you want to quickly sling the bag over one shoulder.

3. Durability and Construction

Both duffel bags and camping backpacks can be built to handle rough outdoor conditions, but they face different challenges. Look for duffels that use high-denier fabrics, tough metal zips, and reinforced stitching to ensure they can handle being tossed around and packed tightly.

Duffels often have simpler construction with fewer potential failure points. Fewer zippers, straps, and attachment points could break. This simplicity can make them more durable in rough handling situations.

Backpacks, while more complex, are designed to handle the specific stresses of being carried on your back. The multiple attachment points, reinforced areas, and sophisticated suspension systems are built to distribute forces and prevent wear in critical areas.

4. Organization and Accessibility 

This is perhaps the most significant practical difference between the two options. Camping backpacks are designed with organization in mind. Multiple compartments, internal pockets, side pockets, and external attachment points mean you can organize your gear logically and access specific items without unpacking everything.

Duffels take the opposite approach. The single large compartment means everything goes in together. While this can be frustrating when you need to find a specific item at the bottom of the bag, it also makes packing easier and maximizes space efficiency.

Some modern duffels try to bridge this gap with internal organization features. Internal organization features, such as pockets, are becoming more common, but they still don’t match the organizational capabilities of a dedicated backpack.

5. Weather Protection and Special Features 

Both types of bags can offer excellent weather protection, but they approach it differently. Waterproof duffels are great for long trips on the river or short hikes through rainstorms with camping gear you need to keep dry. The simple construction of duffels often makes it easier to create a completely waterproof design.

Many camping backpacks include built-in rain covers or are made from water-resistant materials. However, the multiple zippers and access points can create more opportunities for water to get in.

Some duffels also come with wheels, creating a hybrid option. Rolling duffels merge the convenience of a duffel with the ease of standard wheeled suitcases and are great for carrying heavy loads over smooth surfaces. This can be perfect for car camping, where you have smooth surfaces to roll your gear across.

6. Weight Consideration 

When every ounce matters, the choice between a duffel bag and a camping backpack becomes crucial. The lighter a bag, the better for any outdoor adventure where you’ll be carrying your gear.

Generally, duffels can be lighter than backpacks of similar capacity because they have simpler construction. Without the complex suspension systems, multiple zippers, and reinforced areas that backpacks require, a duffel can save significant weight.

However, this weight savings comes at the cost of carrying comfort. A lighter duffel that’s uncomfortable to carry defeats the purpose if you’re hiking with it. The weight distribution benefits of a heavier backpack often make the total experience more comfortable despite the extra weight.

7. Cost and Value Considerations 

Budget-conscious campers will find that duffels generally offer better value for raw storage capacity. The simpler construction typically means lower costs for similar storage volumes. They are cheap and offer straightforward functionality without paying for complex features you might not need.

Camping backpacks, especially those designed for serious outdoor use, typically cost more due to their sophisticated design and construction. However, they offer value in comfort, organization, and specialized features that can make your camping experience significantly better.

Consider your intended use carefully. If you’re car camping occasionally, an inexpensive duffel might serve you perfectly. If you’re planning regular backpacking trips, investing in a quality camping backpack will pay dividends in comfort and functionality.

Duffel Bag vs Camping Backpack: Quick Comparison

Making the Right Choice for Your Camping Style

The decision between a duffel bag and a camping backpack ultimately comes down to how you camp. If you’re just road tripping, a streamlined duffel with drop handles is all you need. But if you’re walking through an airport or hiking with the bag, you’ll want something with a shoulder strap, or, even better, backpack straps.

For car camping, cabin stays, and base camp situations where you won’t be carrying your gear far, a duffel bag offers maximum storage capacity and easy packing. The ability to see all your gear at once and the spacious interior make organization simple.

For backpacking, hiking to remote campsites, and any scenario where you’ll be carrying your gear significant distances, a camping backpack is essential. The comfort, organization, and hands-free carrying capability make them worth the extra cost and complexity.

Many experienced campers actually own both types of bags and choose based on their specific trip. A duffel for the family car camping trip, a backpack for the solo wilderness adventure.

Frequently Asked Questions